[nSLUG] Please do not use Reply for new topics

Daniel Morrison draker at gmail.com
Fri Oct 9 12:36:52 ADT 2009

2009/10/9 Ben Armstrong <synrg at sanctuary.nslug.ns.ca>:
> Gmail doesn't thread.  It apparently sorts by subject (with some
> fuzziness allowed) and subsorts by date.  Proper threading is
> linked by references in the headers and is immune to subject changes.
> I consider it to be useful to know when an original thread has
> branched into a sub-discussion, so I prefer proper threading.

Some pretty strong language about what is "proper" threading and what
isn't, Ben! :)

Obviously someone simply replying and changing the subject for an
unrelated message is not "branching into a sub-discussion". In the
good old days we used "Subject: New subject (WAS: old subject)" in
order to make the distinction clear.

Seems to me that Gmail works better with real-life human behaviour,
and nabble doesn't, so how does that make it "proper threading"? Ivory

Here's a joke:

One day this guy is finally fed up with his middle-class existence and
decides to do something about it.  He calls up his best friend, who is a
mathematical genius.  "Look," he says, "do you suppose you could find some
way mathematically of guaranteeing winning at the race track?  We could
make a lot of money and retire and enjoy life."  The mathematician thinks
this over a bit and walks away mumbling to himself.
	A week later his friend drops by to ask the genius if he's had any
success.  The genius, looking a little bleary-eyed, replies, "Well, yes,
actually I do have an idea, and I'm reasonably sure that it will work, but
there a number of details to be figured out.
	After the second week the mathematician appears at his friend's house,
looking quite a bit rumpled, and announces, "I think I've got it! I still have
some of the theory to work out, but now I'm certain that I'm on the right
	At the end of the third week the mathematician wakes his friend by
pounding on his door at three in the morning.  He has dark circles under his
eyes.  His hair hasn't been combed for many days.  He appears to be wearing
the same clothes as the last time.  He has several pencils sticking out from
behind his ears and an almost maniacal expression on his face.  "WE CAN DO
IT!  WE CAN DO IT!!" he shrieks. "I have discovered the perfect solution!!
And it's so EASY!  First, we assume that horses are perfect spheres in simple
harmonic motion..."


More information about the nSLUG mailing list